|
Procedural Representation and Elite Backlash: Experiences of Everyday Discrimination Faced by Scheduled Caste Village Presidents in India
AMOL SHAILA SURESH |
|
Academic Article
The Graduate Inequality Review, Volume 5 (October 2026), pp. 13-24 |
|
Abstract:
When India’s 73rd Constitutional Amendment took effect, Scheduled Castes were elected to village leadership positions in unprecedented numbers. However, procedural representation does not simply translate into substantive empowerment, as SC leaders encounter dynamic resistance aimed to undermine their de facto authority. In this article, I investigate how independent SC village presidents in Bihar, India – those who resist proxy status and exercise authority in their own right – experience and perceive backlash. This study draws on semi-structured, in-depth interviews with three SC village presidents (or mukhiyas[1]) who have resisted traditional proxy leadership arrangements. The findings reveal that: (1) formal procedural representation often fails to generate substantive authority, and (2) independent SC leaders who resist proxy status face a multi-dimensional backlash – ranging from systematic bureaucratic obstruction to social microaggressions and the physical destruction of symbolic icons. This research highlights the systematic ways substantive democracy is undermined through everyday exclusion and the necessity of transforming underlying power structures alongside institutional reforms. ---- [1] Mukhiya is a Hindi term for the elected head of a village council (gram panchayat). I use words ‘village president’ and ‘mukhiya’ interchangeably. |
Full Text: